The Fourth Path

Watching Others Practicing Piano is… Quite Fun!

Posted in NTU, Piano, Singapore by nmutiara on 2008/12/25

Sometimes I wonder what NTU PE members practice in Music Room 2. So, I decided to watch some of them, whom I think quite interesting to be examined.

I’ve  (secretly) watched at least 8 people practicing piano in the music room (on each of their timeslots, of course). Here are some of my conclusions.

Stuff Practiced

  • Some members spend all their time to (sight)read (hard) pieces.
    These people are usually good sightreaders. Some said that they don’t memorize well.
  • Some other practice memorized pieces only.
    They have good memory. Most of these people sightread slowly or too shy to sightread.
  • Several of them practice learnt pieces.
    This can be re-reading (not sightreading!) pieces or practicing memorized pieces.
  • The rest practice pieces to be performed on concerts, exams, etc.
  • Very few people practice improvisation

Motivation to Practice

Sometimes I ask them why they practice. Sometimes they told me their opinions about playing piano or the pieces they played.

I usually perceive some of their words as their motivations to practice. The following are not necessarily true.

  • Some people practice if and only if important events will take place.
    Important events = Exams, performances, concerts, etc.
  • Some other practice because of being motivated after looking at others playing piano.
    Well.. this kind of motivation can be…
    “Other people play very nicely. They’re cool! I must practice hard!”
    Hey, that piece I also can play!” “Hey, I can also play that piece!”
    “Huh? Am I the only one who could play that piece?” 
  • Several members think there are interesting pieces to learn (sightread).
    This is usually because they have ever heard the piece. Err… so they don’t purely sightread… [But if the pieces are just too hard to read, that can be called sightreading!]

After getting all those conclusions, I can reflect upon myself. I usually practice learnt pieces. I am motivated after looking others playing piano and when there are interesting pieces to learn.
Sometimes I sightread. However, I usually stop in the middle because of being “frustrated” of listening to my own playing. After that, I go back to the first page which I have memorized a bit.
Hmm… one more thing… I have the worst d nervous system among others.  When I practice, I rarely have mistakes. When I perform (especially in front of unknown people), I shake very badly. This causes me to make mistakes which are not supposed to be made…

Hmm… I guess this should be made as survey form or so… :P

Tagged with: , , ,

3 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. sfrack said, on 2008/12/26 at 9:49 pm

    I find your post absolutely fascinating! I am a piano teacher and after reading your post, I thought that what you observed is probably how my students “practice”. The overall theme is people like familiarity. They “practice” what they already can play or have heard enough to pick it up. They are not truly practicing. So as a piano teacher, how do I get kids to really practice? I will blog and contemplate on this.
    In continuing with your pursuit, you may want to check out my site: sfrack.wordpress.com
    Thanks!

  2. silentknight20 said, on 2009/02/06 at 2:35 pm

    pasti kaliber2 tingkat tinggi yg notnya bertumpuk2 dan dimainkan sangat cepat…..

    gimana yah caranya byar bs sightread dengan lancar :?
    gw cenderung menghapal…meskipun niatnya mau sightread, tp ujung2nya malah hapal sendiri…… = =;;

  3. nmutiara said, on 2009/02/06 at 3:11 pm

    hmm ga juga si… pas gw lagi lewat, macem2 yang gw liat :P

    tapi emang sebagian besar gw liat itu yang pada lebih jago daripada gw.

    caranya… ya sering2 latian sight read. harus kuat ngedengerin lo sendiri main pake banyak salah dan ngga enak.

    gw juga punya kecendrungan kayak lo, ujung2nya malah ngapal.


Leave a Reply